Hooked provides the experience that most people wish they had when they first visited Nobu or other trendy Japanese fusion restaurants.
The funny part is we ended up dining at Hooked in Beaver Creek by chance. The reviews of this restaurant are, frankly, bad, and the only reason we ended up here was because they had an open reservation near 6 PM on short notice.
We were blown away by the selection, the service, and the whole fish preparations. We're critical, we're experienced, we've been around the block. Hooked was a consensus top ten all-time pick amongst my party of three.
We ordered oysters, caviar, two different whole fish, and fries. The bill, even with a half-bottle of Champagne and a bottle of sake, wasn't outrageous compared to any other high-end Asian fusion restaurant. It wasn't even our highest bill in Beaver Creek. It was our most memorable dining experience of this trip by a long shot.
I returned the next day for lunch and it was still great. The menu is puzzling, absolutely, but there are few seafood restaurants at ski resorts that even attempt to carry selections this broad.
The negative reviews need to be discounted significantly. While it is plausible that a few people got swindled by the expensive whole fish, you can look back through several years of negative reviews and realize that it's mainly people complaining about cancelation policies, the food being "expensive," or the unhelpful "bad service."
One of the few reviews featuring any real qualifiers suggests that Uchi in Dallas is superior. The funny thing is that I ate at Uchi in Austin with one of my friends I dined at Hooked with and we agree it was a "generic expensive Japanese restaurant."
If you are looking for a premium meal in the vicinity of $200pp+, this is it. Stop spending your money at steakhouses.